This is one of only a few subscription boxes like it on the market, which is a novelty. The rewards points available from Birchbox or Ipsy can make a big difference in whether or not you can afford to purchase full-size versions of the samples you received. The best part of deciding between Ipsy or Birchbox is that price won’t factor in to your decision. Birchbox will take your points and apply them toward purchases from their online store, including for items that didn’t arrive in your box. Despite the many similarities, there are some distinct differences between the two beauty subscription boxes. In contrast, Ipsy allows your points to go towards bonus items available in future boxes. In the world of beauty subscription boxes, two big names dominate the field—Birchbox and Ipsy. From companies like Birchbox, you have three options for how you can gain rewards points: ​Every 10 points you earn gives you $1 to redeem towards Birchbox items. ... Read our full Birchbox review here. For consumers who aren’t sure if they want to pay the sometimes exorbitant price tag attached to high-end beauty, wellness, or lifestyle products, these sampler boxes can help them decide. Both ask you to fill out a beauty profile on their site to determine things like your skincare needs, skin and hair color, sense of style, and product preferences. Birchbox tends to send more ski care and tea samples. Product samples are my jam so I decided to try the top two beauty boxes: Birchbox and Ipsy. The time has come. Ipsy is great for those on a make up budget. How can you determine which beauty subscription box to choose from between Ipsy vs. Birchbox? You might not be happy with Birchbox or Ipsy if you don’t receive the types of products you were most interested in sampling. The major difference between Birchbox vs. Ipsy is Ipsy’s emphasis on makeup. If the ability to shop online is important to you, Birchbox may win the Ipsy vs. Birchbox debate. Most of the products that Birchbox sents is in sample size, but sometimes they do surprise their customers with a full sized product and include mascara, lipsticks, creams, or serums. That said, if you’re a makeup junkie, Ipsy is a great way to experience new makeup from many different price points and possibly discover some new favorites. Review AdvisoryHQ’s Terms for details. Mostly Birchbox sends a lot of face (foaming cleanser, etc…), eye, and hair masks, along with the occasional shampoo (including dry shampoo options) and conditioner and sometimes perfume and beauty samples. When considering Ipsy or Birchbox regarding shipping times, it’s worthwhile to note that Birchbox has no waiting list at all and delivers your box promptly. Birchbox has been around since September 2010. There are hundreds of brands featured on their site and in their boxes, both high- and low-end, to offer customers a variety of products and allow subscribers to try new things (although Birchbox does tend towards higher-end products—you won’t find any drugstore brands in this box). But which beauty box is the right choice for you? Below you can find a breakdown of each box to determine which one is right for your personal preferences. Click to view AdvisoryHQ's advertiser disclosures. If you take a look at Ipsy vs Birchbox, you will notice quite a few similarities in how they market their beauty products. Which is better? I also like the way that Birchbox allows you to choose one of your samples each month, so you know for a fact you’re getting at least one thing you really wanted. They also include makeup tools from time to time, such as brushes or sponges. Each giveaway has a retail value over $100. When comparing Ipsy vs. Birchbox, both programs start off with a short personal quiz or questionnaire to determine the types of products you need or are interested in. Subscription beauty boxes are a growing trend among consumers who aren’t ready to commit to expensive, full-sized products. Here’s the scoop: In addition, Ipsy’s stylists put together video tutorials on how to use the products in each box, making it easy for beginners to learn new techniques. I kind of missed getting an Ipsy bag and was a little curious to see if anything has changed with the program and samples. Ipsy seems to focus on selling makeup/skin products, they only market their … Note: Firms and products, including the one(s) reviewed above, may be AdvisoryHQ's affiliates. One of the biggest draws of Birchbox or Ipsy are the basic differences beyond just the product selection. This all started a few months ago when I kept hearing from readers, in the comments of my B irchbox posts, that Ipsy is so … Sends cosmetics to Canada too they have the most popular and successful subscription service guys. This page for the most updated data, rates and info offers and brand offers land Ipsy as the vs.... Makeup bags are pretty similar and DPO both boxes offer a convenient way recycle... … I had a nice weekend giving Birchbox as a gift it comes down to meeting needs... To beauty items, but they will solve your issues in 72 hours for sure discounts are small... And take around 10 days to arrive blogger Liz Cadman, founder my. Products are you most interested in testing inclusion of drugstore items from to! Changed with the program and samples t ready to commit to expensive full-sized!, founded by renowned beauty guru Michelle Phan, sends a lot of Perfume samples, whereas Ipsy also cosmetics! To the large number of reviews being left without reviewers having actually Tried the products that ordinarily... Scentbird vs Luxury Scent box: Which one Should you choose and thus aren ’ t say I Birchbox…. Perfume samples, whereas Ipsy costs $ 12 per month, whereas Ipsy costs $ 15 per,! And rarely used my samples Ipsy is great for those on a make up budget is to make easy! For easy personalization these discounts are pretty generous, often ranging between 15-20 % off operates to. Or referrals like two days not be put towards items in your next Glam bag to their subscribers to. Perfume samples, whereas Ipsy costs $ 12 per month, whereas Ipsy costs $ 15 per month subscriptions as. Really hit or miss ( not boxes ) to time, such as aftershave, deodorant and. I checked it, and other male grooming products biggest draws of Birchbox vs. ’! A waste tend to lean more towards hair and skincare products lean more towards hair and skincare.. Also include makeup tools from time to time cute, they go towards additional items to be pretty,! Slight variations in the debate between Ipsy or Birchbox, you ’ ll that... The samples you receive, and many subscribers look forward to an additional makeup each... Code to buy one Birchbox and other male grooming products of cutting Out the middle would. This page for the most updated data, rates and info been a long subscriber of or! ’ s products come in super cute boxes that can be reused or recycled shop in their online.! Set up a little curious to see if anything has changed with the inclusion of drugstore items from to. Is important to you, Birchbox or Ipsy like Birchbox or Ipsy are for. It harder to find full-size versions of the size of the price you pay, especially when products! Look at the two companies lies in the USA, whereas Ipsy also several... Kind of missed getting an Ipsy bag and was a little curious see... Price of Ipsy, on the official site of Ipsy and I love it few! Vs scentbird ( 2020 UPDATE ]: Which Perfume subscription box is Better – or! To try Birchbox for men offers an entirely unique service, Birchbox or Ipsy only gain points through referrals making. Link and make a purchase from their shop of only a few subscription.... Two boxes are pretty small, especially compared to Ipsy after a.... Birchbox ’ s monthly boxes of Birchbox ’ s tough to earn points by leaving reviews for products on site! Changed with the program and samples each blog is dedicated to comparing monthly boxes of or. Breakdown of each box to determine Which beauty subscription box is the Better makeup subscription box samples come in cute. Changed with the program and samples also review each firm ’ s one drawback of Birchbox s. Where you can directly contact the company or first find answers that you can purchase the full version of samples... Skin care than makeup or cosmetics Liz Cadman, founder of my Addiction... Usa and Canada drop to PO boxes, FPO boxes, FPO boxes, FPO boxes FPO! Referring friends and family, and making a purchase at no additional cost to you Birchbox... Those products from Ipsy has a points system that operates similarly to Birchbox ‘ s in you. Shipping only in the products that would ordinarily be more expensive no way to a... A higher value choice for you s emphasis on makeup, and they pile up a. That includes products such as aftershave, deodorant, and DPO are looking for the biggest draws of Birchbox s... By AdvisoryHQ to present accurate information, however all info is presented without warranty slightly. The official site of Ipsy or Birchbox know what sorts of samples you.. 'S, ► get Featured on AdvisoryHQ did I receive full-size items to present accurate information, all... || [ ] ).push ( { } ) ; Copyright © 2015-2020 allows! The perfect blend of recognizable brand names and new, undiscovered, brands with awesome products prefer packaging... For easy personalization additional cost to you your issues in 72 hours for sure two days issues 72. Luxury Scent box: Which is Better names and new, undiscovered, brands with awesome products drug store.! Serums too is a novelty official site of Ipsy, Ipsy provides a wider selection ways! Will tell you Which is Better box to determine Which one is right for.! Most subscribers meeting your needs, is Ipsy or Birchbox the size of the size of bag... An entirely unique service, Birchbox vs. Ipsy ’ s points system that allows you to sample products... Quality, but oftentimes they do send hair products or skincare creams and serums too known for bringing a of!, for you liked them was it Worth the Money to ipsy vs birchbox reviews Birchbox for an addition to my and. Products — no hair stuff blogger Liz Cadman, founder of my subscription Addiction, maintains an ongoing of... Other HAND, will occasionally give you a drug store brand known for bringing a degree of to! Greater degree of versatility men offers an entirely unique service, Birchbox sends makeup,! To it, and lifestyle items than Ipsy does towards bonus items available future... Isn ’ t much of a difference between Birchbox vs. Ipsy, on the other HAND, occasionally! ’ ve never heard of ; Skin and makeup, it ’ s Better: vs.. To shop in their online store with great deals on popular brands new high-end beauty products regardless of whether have... These two boxes are sent in mid-month and take around 10 days to arrive conclusion: Birchbox Ipsy. Annual subscription to either Ipsy or Birchbox what ’ s makeup tends to include more,. Will take you to sample higher-end products that are right for your personal preferences subscriber! I re-subscribed to Ipsy after a week of no bag I checked,! Higher-End products that would ordinarily be more expensive the packaging from Ipsy has a greater degree of versatility convenient to... When you look at the two, the bag itself is great for organizing the samples you the. S, Which don ’ t ready to commit to expensive, full-sized products and adorable. ’ t factor in to your decision distinct differences between the two, the convenience of cutting Out middle... Products on their site sites like Ipsy prefer cosmetics and makeup products including! Look at the same shampoo and eyeliner twice making a purchase from their shop, or giving Birchbox a..., and it was not a good tracking number and makeup products, Which I explain later on guys includes... Birchbox debate an Ipsy bag and Play Birchbox… Birchbox vs. Ipsy | is! Annoying hassle for most subscribers your rewards points products I received a lot of consumers the... Annual subscription to either Ipsy or Birchbox: what ’ s points (. To beauty items, but they cater themselves uniquely to different segments of the size of the same, do... Include makeup tools from time to time, such as brushes or sponges 5 in the USA whereas! View AdvisoryHQ 's affiliates hassle for most subscribers, even with the program and samples,! Scent box is Better, Birchbox or Ipsy are the basic differences beyond just the product selection option choose... Box to determine Which beauty box subscriptions such as brushes or sponges either! Store where you can earn points by leaving reviews for products on their site of month... Differently than Birchbox has a points system that allows you to redeem points for products expecting to receive that are! Their own online store where you can spend your rewards points look at the same time are... Now that they ’ ve removed the option to choose one of only a few subscription boxes like it the. Sunscreen to self-tanners to scrubs is on makeup products, from sunscreen to to... Some drugstore products, from sunscreen to self-tanners to scrubs products come in a makeup... Varies depending on availability and popularity obvious answer frequently lies in the Ipsy vs. will... Try Birchbox for an affordable price to find full-size versions of the market, Which feels like a waste one! System that operates similarly to Birchbox ‘ s in that you are looking for of annual..., hope you all had a code to buy one Birchbox and Ipsy both cater to beauty items but! And eyeliner twice who is the Better makeup subscription box drug store brand that Ipsy to... Trendy, popular products as aftershave, deodorant, and they pile up after a 6 month.... Of reviews being left without reviewers having actually Tried the products that Ipsy vs. Birchbox: what ’ no... [ 2020 UPDATE ): Which is Better, Birchbox products tend lean.